Holacracy Community of Practice Archive, 2015-2019 Community Holacracy Web Site

Cohesion in the GCC

Hi Everyone,

We're in the early adoption phase and are currently conducting some of our first GCC governance meetings. Through the coach training I learnt about coupling and cohesion and realised that we had a created a sub circle full of roles that had very low cohesion and high coupling, a circle full of roles that no one knew what to do with, so put them in an imaginary clutter drawer. This circle is a sub circle which now no longer exists, so all of these roles now sit in the super circle which is a sub circle of the GCC. 

In GCC governance I proposed that we remove two of these roles and bring them into the GCC due to low cohesion with the rest of the circle. This was met with a valid objection from the GCC LL, with the main reason being that these roles also had low cohesion with the GCC. This didn't seem right to me, as I imagine that the GCC would always be full of roles with low cohesion or high coupling. 

It was a tricky governance tension with the proposer and objector getting a bit stuck at integration. The objector felt like the only way to solve the objection was to drop the proposal, meaning that the objection became invalid.

I wonder if anyone has any feedback on this? Is cohesion important in the GCC?

Thanks in advance



No Replies